Rent or Buy: The Great Debate
A case for both renting or buying in London can easily be made, but which option should first-time buyers be aiming for?
With such polarised opinions on which option is smarter financially, economically and in the long-term, deciding whether to rent or buy is a difficult decision for anyone stepping onto the property ladder for the first time. But despite an increase in people choosing to rent, buying may actually save you money over time.
Rent vs. Buy
Renting can be a worthwhile option for anyone needing flexibility, and with the high transaction costs of buying, mortgage fees, stamp duty and more, renting is also easier on the budget over the short term. However, according to a study on buying versus renting done for the International Review of Financial Analysis, an “increases in inflation and imputed rent top the balance in favour of ownership”.
Gap Between Buying and Renting is Narrowing
Despite a growing rental market in London and rental costs more affordable across more than half of British cities, data suggests the gap between buying and renting is narrowing. Halifax data shows that buying is financially better for first-timers in the long run as those looking to enter the property market can save up to £651 a year by buying rather than renting. The gap between the cost of buying and renting has narrowed by £19 a month since 2016, which is largely due to the rise in house prices for first-time buyers.
House Prices in the UK Continue to Grow
Property prices in the UK have risen by 5.4% compared to last year, with the average property price in London increasing from £472,718 in December 2016 to £483,568 in September 2017 according to the UK Land Registry. On the other hand, average weekly earnings for employees in Britain fell by 0.4% in the last year.
The Number of Renters Has More than Doubled in London
According to trends, more people are opting to rent in London than buy. Data between 1996 and 2016 shows that private renting has more than doubled, while the growth of owner-occupied homes has been much slower.
| London | 1996 | 2016 |
| Owner-occupied | 1,638,000 | 1,666,000 |
| Private renters | 400,000 | 829,000 |
This is largely due to property price increases rapidly outstripping average wage growth and the fact that many first-time homeowners are unable to save enough for a deposit, with the average deposit for a London property being £94,088. As a result, the age of people entering the UK property market for the first time is highest in the capital at 32-years old while research shows around 29% require help from parents to pay a deposit.
Read: More Parents Helping First-Time Buyer Kids Step onto the Property Ladder Than Ever Before
31% of UK Millennials Own their Own Home
Research by HSBC, which studied over 9000 people in nine countries, revealed that four of every ten millennials own their own home. China ranks highest with 70% of millennials owning a home, compared to 31% in the UK.
| Country | % of millennials who own their own homes |
| China | 70% |
| Mexico | 46% |
| France | 41% |
| Malaysia | 35% |
| United States | 35% |
| Canada | 34% |
| United Kingdom | 31% |
| Australia | 28% |
| United Arab Emirates | 26% |
Buy Vs Rent: London Property Prices Compared
We analysed average property and rental prices from data.london.gov.uk and calculated how much mortgage repayments would be over 25 years at 2.5% interest with a 10% deposit.
Read: Buying vs Renting a House in the UK
Where Should First-Time Buyers Step onto the Property Ladder in London?
Speak to an expert at Douglas and Gordon to find the ideal property in London.
Sources
www.hsbc.com/news-and-insight/media-resources/media-releases/2017/generation-buy